Frontly vs Hiring a Receptionist
A front desk hire costs far more than the salary line, works 40 hours of the 168 in a week, and takes one call at a time. Frontly Answer covers all 168, answers several callers at once, and books the appointment during the call. Here is the honest comparison, including what a person still does better.
- Loaded cost: a front desk hire runs roughly $50,000 to $70,000 a year once payroll taxes, benefits, time off and turnover are counted
- Coverage: one hire covers about 40 hours a week, and the calls that arrive at 7pm or on a Saturday are the ones that go unanswered
- Concurrency: one person takes one call at a time, so a rush goes to voicemail
- Consistency: the same qualifying questions get asked on every call, and every call is transcribed
- A person is still better at walk-ins, judgment calls and reading a difficult conversation, which is why most businesses run both
Coverage
| Feature | Frontly | Hiring a Receptionist |
|---|---|---|
| Hours covered per week | 168 | About 40 |
| Nights, weekends and federal holidays | Yes | Overtime or uncovered |
| Several calls answered at once | Yes | No |
| Unaffected by sick days and vacation | Yes | No |
| Scales instantly at peak | Yes | No |
| No recruiting or turnover risk | Yes | No |
Hours covered per week
Frontly
168Hiring a Receptionist
About 40Nights, weekends and federal holidays
Frontly
YesHiring a Receptionist
Overtime or uncoveredSeveral calls answered at once
Frontly
YesHiring a Receptionist
NoUnaffected by sick days and vacation
Frontly
YesHiring a Receptionist
NoScales instantly at peak
Frontly
YesHiring a Receptionist
NoNo recruiting or turnover risk
Frontly
YesHiring a Receptionist
NoOn the call
| Feature | Frontly | Hiring a Receptionist |
|---|---|---|
| Same qualifying questions every time | Yes | Varies |
| Full transcript of every call | Yes | No |
| Appointment booked during the call | Yes | Yes |
| Cross-call memory of returning callers | Yes | Varies |
| Multiple languages | Yes | Rare |
| Never distracted by the person at the counter | Yes | No |
Same qualifying questions every time
Frontly
YesHiring a Receptionist
VariesFull transcript of every call
Frontly
YesHiring a Receptionist
NoAppointment booked during the call
Frontly
YesHiring a Receptionist
YesCross-call memory of returning callers
Frontly
YesHiring a Receptionist
VariesMultiple languages
Frontly
YesHiring a Receptionist
RareNever distracted by the person at the counter
Frontly
YesHiring a Receptionist
NoAnnual cost of one hire
| Feature | Frontly | Hiring a Receptionist |
|---|---|---|
| Base pay | See /pricing | $38K to $52K |
| Employer payroll taxes at 7.65% | None | $2.9K to $4.0K |
| Health insurance and benefits | None | $6K to $12K |
| Paid time off, sick days and holidays | None | 3 to 4 weeks a year |
| Workers' compensation | None | $300 to $1.5K |
| Training and onboarding | None | $2K to $5K |
| Recruiting when they leave | None | $3K to $8K |
| Loaded annual cost | See /pricing | Roughly $50K to $70K |
Base pay
Frontly
See /pricingHiring a Receptionist
$38K to $52KEmployer payroll taxes at 7.65%
Frontly
NoneHiring a Receptionist
$2.9K to $4.0KHealth insurance and benefits
Frontly
NoneHiring a Receptionist
$6K to $12KPaid time off, sick days and holidays
Frontly
NoneHiring a Receptionist
3 to 4 weeks a yearWorkers' compensation
Frontly
NoneHiring a Receptionist
$300 to $1.5KTraining and onboarding
Frontly
NoneHiring a Receptionist
$2K to $5KRecruiting when they leave
Frontly
NoneHiring a Receptionist
$3K to $8KLoaded annual cost
Frontly
See /pricingHiring a Receptionist
Roughly $50K to $70KWhere a person still wins
| Feature | Frontly | Hiring a Receptionist |
|---|---|---|
| Greeting people who walk in | No | Yes |
| Judgment on an unusual situation | Transfers to your team | Yes |
| Reading tone and de-escalating | Escalates to your team | Yes |
| Everything that is not a phone call | No | Yes |
Greeting people who walk in
Frontly
NoHiring a Receptionist
YesJudgment on an unusual situation
Frontly
Transfers to your teamHiring a Receptionist
YesReading tone and de-escalating
Frontly
Escalates to your teamHiring a Receptionist
YesEverything that is not a phone call
Frontly
NoHiring a Receptionist
YesDEEP DIVE
Key Differences Explained
Base pay is roughly two thirds of the real number
A front desk hire in the US typically starts somewhere between $38,000 and $52,000 depending on the market and the practice. On top of that sit employer payroll taxes at 7.65 percent, the employer share of health insurance, paid time off, workers' compensation, training, and the cost of recruiting a replacement when they move on, which for this role happens more often than most owners plan for. Loaded, one seat is usually in the $50,000 to $70,000 range, and it still only covers about 40 hours a week. Typical US private-industry benchmarks, August 2026, indicative only.
40 hours covered out of 168
The hours a receptionist does not work are not quiet hours. Evenings, early mornings, weekends and holidays are when people who are at work all day make their own appointments, and those calls either reach voicemail or reach a competitor. Frontly answers all 168 hours at the same monthly rate, which is the part of the comparison that has nothing to do with cost per hour.
One call at a time is the real bottleneck
Even during covered hours, one person takes one call. The second caller waits, the third goes to voicemail, and the person standing at the counter gets half of your receptionist's attention while all of it happens. Frontly answers callers in parallel, so a burst after an ad runs or a listing goes live is handled rather than triaged.
This is usually an augmentation decision, not a replacement one
Most businesses that adopt Frontly keep their front desk person. The AI takes overflow, after-hours and the repetitive calls, and the person handles walk-ins, relationships and anything that needs judgment. That is a better use of a good receptionist than having them read out opening hours for the ninth time today, and it is a far easier decision than replacing someone.
What you should not expect from an AI front desk
It does not greet the person who walks through your door, it does not do the twenty other jobs a front desk person picks up during the day, and it does not improvise its way through a genuinely unusual conversation. It transfers those to your team. If the role you are hiring for is mostly not-the-phone, this comparison is the wrong one and you should hire.
How Pricing Compares
Frontly Answer is the inbound AI front desk, billed at a flat monthly rate and sized by monthly minute allowance, with no payroll taxes, benefits, cover or turnover attached. Sizes and inclusions are on /pricing.
Base pay of roughly $38K to $52K plus employer payroll taxes, benefits, paid time off, workers' compensation, training and recruiting. Typical US private-industry benchmarks, August 2026, indicative only. Check them against your own payroll.
INDUSTRY FIT
Is Frontly right for your industry?
AI receptionist for dental practices loses its front desk to the chair constantly, so calls go unanswered while the receptionist you are already paying is helping the patient in front of them.
AI intake reception for law firms pays intake staff to be available for inquiries that arrive unpredictably, and the inquiry that arrives at 8pm is frequently the one worth the most.
AI reception for property managers gets the concurrency argument most clearly: one receptionist takes one call at a time, and a burst pipe on a Friday night generates several at once.
AI after-hours front desk is the part no single hire covers at all. Nights and weekends are an on-call rotation, an answering service or voicemail, and each of those costs you something different.
AI front desk for hotels cannot roster somebody across every hour a guest might call, and the overnight calls are frequently the ones carrying a reservation.
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
HEAR IT FOR YOURSELF
Your AI Agent Is Ready to Talk
Call our AI agent right now. No signup. No credit card. Just dial and experience it.
Talk to the agent now
Talk to the AI agent right now from your browser. Hear exactly how Frontly will sound for your business.
Ready to Stop Missing Leads?
Set up your AI front desk in about an hour. No credit card required.